The Right of First Refusal (ROFR) in real estate grants a specific party (usually a tenant or neighbor) the first opportunity to purchase a property before the seller can offer it to other potential buyers. If the holder of the right declines, the seller is free to move forward with another buyer. ROFR is commonly seen in situations like leasing or shared properties where stakeholders may want a chance to secure ownership.
This guide will explain the ins and outs of ROFR, including how it works, its benefits and drawbacks, and key real estate scenarios. Let’s dive in:
What Is a Right of First Refusal in Real Estate?
In real estate, a Right of First Refusal (ROFR) is a contractual right that gives a person or entity the opportunity to buy a property before the owner can sell it to someone else. If the property owner decides to sell, they must first offer it to the individual or group holding the ROFR.
If you’re renting a home, for example, your lease agreement might include a clause giving you the right to purchase the property if the landlord decides to sell. If the landlord gets an offer from another buyer, you get the first chance to match that offer.
What Is an Example of the First Right of Refusal Clause?
A typical Right of First Refusal clause might read like this:
“If the property owner receives a bona fide offer from a third party, the holder of the right will have 30 days to match the offer under the same terms.”
This clause ensures the holder gets a window of opportunity before the property is sold to anyone else.
Here’s a practical scenario: A homeowner decides to sell their property and receives an offer of $300,000. Before accepting the offer, they must give the ROFR holder (such as a tenant or a neighbor) the opportunity to buy it under the same terms.
How a Right of First Refusal Works
The Right of First Refusal (ROFR) process begins when the property owner decides to sell. Here's how the steps unfold in more detail:
Offer Received:
Once a third-party buyer makes an offer, the seller must notify the ROFR holder. This offer includes all the terms of the sale, such as price, contingencies, and deadlines.
Notification:
The seller provides formal notification to the ROFR holder, typically in writing, detailing the buyer’s offer. This allows the holder to make an informed decision.
Decision Period:
The ROFR holder is given a specific window (usually 30 to 60 days) to decide whether to exercise their right. This timeframe allows the holder to arrange financing, perform due diligence, or negotiate any terms.
The holder may want to inspect the property, appraise its value, and ensure that matching the offer is financially feasible. This is a crucial step since the terms must be met exactly as offered by the third-party buyer.
Learn more:
The Ultimate Guide to the Home Buying Process
10 DIY Home Improvement Ideas to Upgrade Your Home
Acceptance or Decline:
If the holder accepts, they move forward with the transaction under the same terms as the third-party offer. The deal is finalized between the ROFR holder and the seller, and the third-party buyer’s offer is nullified.
If the holder declines, the seller is free to proceed with the original buyer or any subsequent offers. Once the decision is made, the property can be sold without any further obligation to the ROFR holder.
Flexibility:
The ROFR is flexible and beneficial for both parties. The property holder has the opportunity to secure a property at the same price and terms offered by the third party. Meanwhile, the seller can proceed with the sale, ensuring they receive market value for the property.
Key Considerations:
Market Impact: If the third-party offer is exceptionally high, the ROFR holder might face difficulty matching it. On the flip side, the ROFR holder has the potential advantage of securing the property without engaging in a competitive bidding war.
Legal and Financial Preparation: The ROFR holder should be financially prepared and have legal counsel to ensure they can act swiftly. Delays in decision-making or financing can result in the holder missing the opportunity to purchase the property.
Effect on Third-Party Buyers: The existence of an ROFR can sometimes deter third-party buyers from making offers, knowing that their efforts could be overridden by the ROFR holder. Sellers should be transparent about the ROFR to avoid any misunderstandings with prospective buyers.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Rights of First Refusal
Advantages
- For Buyers: A ROFR gives buyers, such as tenants or stakeholders, the first opportunity to purchase a property at the same price offered by an external party. This is especially useful for individuals who have a vested interest in the property or land.
- For Sellers: Sellers can benefit from the stability of a long-term tenant or neighboring landowner being more motivated to purchase the property, reducing the uncertainties that come with new buyers.
- For Both Parties: ROFR can simplify negotiations by setting clear terms upfront, allowing for smoother property transfers. The process is streamlined since the property is offered to the ROFR holder first, saving time that might otherwise be spent searching for other buyers.
Disadvantages
- For Sellers: The primary drawback for sellers is the delay in the sales process. Sellers must give the ROFR holder time to make a decision, which can take 30 to 60 days. If the ROFR holder declines the offer, it could slow down the entire process.
- For Buyers: Although the ROFR holder has first dibs on the property, they may face challenges in securing financing or meeting the terms of the third-party offer. This is especially problematic if the offer is unexpectedly high, making it difficult to match.
- Market Value Risk: An ROFR holder may be forced to match an offer that reflects market inflation or a competitive bid from another buyer. This can make it challenging to secure the property at an affordable price, which could lead the ROFR holder to overextend financially.
What Is the Difference Between an Option to Purchase and a Right of First Refusal?
While both Option to Purchase and Right of First Refusal grant purchase opportunities, they differ in key ways:
- Option to Purchase: The buyer has the right to buy the property within a specific time frame, regardless of whether the seller has received offers from others.
- Right of First Refusal: The buyer only gets the opportunity to purchase if the seller receives an offer from a third party. In other words, the ROFR depends on the seller’s decision to sell.
Should You Agree to a Right of First Refusal?
Agreeing to a Right of First Refusal depends on your long-term goals. If you’re a tenant looking to eventually own the property, an ROFR can provide you with that opportunity. However, sellers should consider whether the ROFR could limit their ability to attract competitive offers or delay the selling process.
Learn more:
Buying a Second Home: Making Income With Rent
The Bottom Line
The Right of First Refusal is a powerful tool in real estate transactions, providing both opportunities and challenges for buyers and sellers alike. Whether you’re a tenant hoping to purchase your rental home or a seller looking to protect your long-term interests, understanding how this clause works can make a big difference in your real estate decisions.
For additional help navigating ROFR and other real estate transactions, feel free to explore the resources on Home Shift Team.
