A home appraisal is a critical aspect of the buying, selling, or refinancing process. It provides an unbiased estimate of a property’s market value, ensuring that lenders, buyers, and sellers have accurate information for making informed decisions.
However, various factors can negatively impact a home appraisal, potentially leading to a lower-than-expected value that affects the entire transaction. Understanding these factors and how to prevent them can help you achieve the best appraisal outcome possible. Want to know what those factors are? So keep reading to find out.
What is a Home Appraisal?
A home appraisal is an independent, professional evaluation of a property’s market value conducted by a licensed appraiser. The appraisal is required by lenders to verify that the home’s value aligns with the mortgage loan amount requested by the buyer. The appraiser evaluates the home’s location, size, condition, and comparable sales in the area, often referred to as "comps", to determine the home’s value.
Learn more:
How Long Does an Appraisal Take? Explained Step by Step
Why is the Appraisal Value Important?
The appraised value is crucial for several reasons:
Loan Approval
Mortgage lenders require an appraisal to ensure that the loan amount aligns with the property’s market value. If the appraisal is lower than the purchase price, the buyer may need to renegotiate the price, increase their down payment, or risk losing the loan approval.
Refinancing Purposes
Homeowners looking to refinance their mortgage need an appraisal to determine their home’s current market value. A low appraisal can limit the amount they can borrow or disqualify them from refinancing altogether.
Selling a Home
Sellers use appraisals to validate their asking price. If the appraisal comes in significantly lower than the sale price, it could lead to renegotiations, price reductions, or even a collapsed deal.
Learn more:
The Importance of Home Inspection: What You Need to Know
What Hurts a Home Appraisal the Most?
There are several factors that can negatively affect a home appraisal, ranging from property condition to external influences. Understanding these factors can help you take proactive steps to avoid a low appraisal.
Poor Property Condition
- Homes showing signs of neglect, such as peeling paint, broken windows, damaged roofs, and outdated fixtures, can significantly reduce the appraisal value. Even minor cosmetic issues like dirty carpets or stained walls can create a negative impression.
- Example: An appraiser may note cracked tiles in the kitchen or a damaged front door, both of which suggest neglect or maintenance issues.
- Tip: Address visible issues before the appraisal. Fresh paint, repairs, and a clean, well-maintained appearance can positively influence the outcome.
Deferred Maintenance and Structural Issues
- Homes with unaddressed maintenance issues, such as leaky roofs, foundation cracks, or outdated electrical systems, may fail to appraise for the desired value. Structural problems are significant red flags that can drastically lower the home’s value.
- Example: If the appraiser finds signs of water damage in the basement or notices a sagging roof, these issues may be reflected in the report.
- Tip: Regular maintenance is key. Before the appraisal, conduct an inspection to identify and fix any major structural problems.
Outdated Systems and Appliances
- Appraisers assess the age and condition of major systems like HVAC, plumbing, and electrical. If these systems are outdated or not functioning properly, they can hurt the home’s value.
- Example: An older HVAC system that is inefficient or in disrepair may lead the appraiser to adjust the home’s value downward.
- Tip: Consider upgrading or servicing essential systems before the appraisal, especially if they are near the end of their life expectancy.
Unpermitted Renovations or Additions
- Any renovations or additions made without proper permits may not be considered in the appraisal. Worse, they may reduce the value if the work is not up to code or poses safety risks.
- Example: An unpermitted bathroom addition could be ignored by the appraiser or flagged as a liability if it doesn’t meet local building standards.
- Tip: Always obtain the necessary permits before making changes to your home. If you have already completed unpermitted work, consider retroactively getting it approved by the city.
External Factors Impacting Property Value
- Factors outside the home can also negatively affect its appraisal. These include a high crime rate, proximity to busy roads or industrial areas, and poorly maintained neighboring properties.
- Example: A property located next to a noisy highway or a landfill site may be appraised lower due to external disturbances.
- Tip: While you can’t control external factors, investing in soundproof windows, landscaping to improve privacy, or maintaining good curb appeal can help mitigate some negative effects.
What Will Fail an Appraisal?
Certain conditions can cause a home to fail an appraisal entirely, impacting the loan approval or the sale of the property:
Health and Safety Hazards
Issues such as mold, asbestos, exposed wiring, or structural damage can cause an appraisal to fail. These problems pose health and safety risks and must be addressed before an appraisal is successful.
Zoning Violations
If your home violates local zoning laws, such as building an addition that encroaches on a neighbor’s property, it could fail the appraisal process.
Environmental Issues
Properties in flood zones, with contaminated soil, or near environmental hazards like power plants may not pass an appraisal due to increased risks and costs associated with these factors.
Learn more:
Home Appraisal Essentials: What Every Buyer and Seller Must Know
What Are the Red Flags for Home Appraisals?
Appraisers look for specific red flags that could indicate potential issues with the home’s value:
Inconsistent Property Records:
If the appraiser finds discrepancies between the property’s official records and its actual condition, such as unrecorded additions, it could negatively affect the appraisal value.
Obvious Signs of Neglect:
Visible signs of neglect, such as overgrown landscaping, peeling paint, or broken fixtures, can lead to a negative impression and a lower value assessment.
Lack of Comparable Sales (Comps):
Appraisers rely on recent sales of similar properties in the area to determine the home’s value. If there are few comparable sales, the appraiser may struggle to justify a higher valuation.
What Do Appraisers Look for During a Home Appraisal?
Appraisers evaluate several factors when determining a property’s value. Here’s a breakdown of what they assess:
1. Location and Neighborhood
Appraisers take into account various aspects of the neighborhood, such as proximity to amenities, safety, and overall appeal. The environment surrounding a property plays a significant role in its valuation.
Examples:
- Proximity to Public Transportation: A property located within walking distance of a major subway station or bus route may receive a higher appraisal because it offers convenient commuting options, which are attractive to buyers.
- Waterfront or Scenic Views: Homes with views of lakes, parks, or city skylines often appraise higher than similar properties without these views.
- Nearby Commercial Developments: A property close to growing commercial areas or new developments, like shopping centers or entertainment districts, may be valued higher due to the increased demand and convenience these areas provide.
2. Size and Layout
The overall square footage, number of rooms, and floor plan efficiency are crucial in determining a property’s value.
Examples:
- Additional Square Footage: A home with a finished basement or an added bonus room that provides extra living space may receive a higher appraisal compared to a similar property without these features.
- Bedroom and Bathroom Count: A three-bedroom, two-bathroom home generally appraised higher than a similar two-bedroom, one-bathroom property because it offers more functionality for families.
- Flexible Spaces: Homes with flexible or multi-use rooms, such as a home office, guest room, or playroom, are often valued higher because they cater to a wide range of needs and lifestyles, which adds appeal.
3. Condition and Quality of the Property
The appraiser examines the overall condition of the home, including the roof, windows, and foundation, as well as the quality of interior finishes.
Examples:
- Roof Condition: A home with a recently replaced roof using high-quality materials will appraise higher than a similar home with an older roof showing signs of wear.
- Foundation and Structural Integrity: If the appraiser notes any cracks or signs of settling in the foundation, it can significantly lower the property value. On the other hand, a home with a solid foundation and a recent structural inspection report may be appraised higher.
- Modern Finishes: Properties featuring high-end finishes such as hardwood floors, quartz countertops, and energy-efficient windows often receive higher valuations than those with dated materials like vinyl flooring or laminate countertops.
4. Upgrades and Renovations
Appraisers consider any improvements or updates made to the property. These upgrades add value, especially when they align with current market trends and neighborhood standards.
Examples:
- Energy-Efficient Features: Installing solar panels, high-efficiency HVAC systems, or double-pane windows can increase the home’s value, particularly in areas where energy efficiency is a priority.
- Smart Home Technology: Homes with integrated smart systems, such as smart thermostats, security systems, and lighting controls, are becoming more desirable, and appraisers may factor these modern conveniences into the home’s value.
- Outdoor Living Spaces: Adding a well-designed deck, patio, or landscaped backyard with amenities like fire pits or outdoor kitchens can increase the value, especially in regions where outdoor living is popular.
- Accessibility Upgrades: Features like walk-in showers, widened doorways, or ramps for wheelchair access may enhance a home’s value, particularly in areas with an aging population or high demand for accessible properties.
Is There a Way to Prevent a Low Home Appraisal?
Absolutely, preventing a low home appraisal requires careful preparation and attention to detail. By taking proactive steps, homeowners can showcase their property in the best possible light, increasing the chances of receiving a favorable valuation. Here are several strategies to help you maximize your appraisal outcome:
Prepare Your Home Thoroughly
- Deep Clean and Declutter: A clean, organized home presents well and shows the appraiser that the property has been well cared for. Deep clean all rooms, paying particular attention to kitchens and bathrooms, as these areas tend to have the most influence on appraisals. Decluttering will help rooms look larger and more inviting.
- Minor Repairs and Touch-Ups: Address small but noticeable issues, such as peeling paint, broken light fixtures, or loose cabinet handles. These small improvements can have a big impact on the overall perception of your home’s condition. Touch up scuffed walls with a fresh coat of paint and ensure that all light bulbs are working, creating a bright and welcoming atmosphere.
- Organize Storage Spaces: Appraisers often look at storage areas such as closets, basements, and garages. Ensure these spaces are tidy, as it gives the impression that the home is functional and offers ample storage, which can positively influence the appraisal.
Provide Comprehensive Documentation
- Record of Upgrades: Have a detailed list of any renovations, upgrades, or improvements you’ve made to the property. Include information like the dates the work was completed, costs, and the contractors used. This helps demonstrate the value you’ve added to your home.
- Permits and Receipts: Ensure that you have all necessary permits for work done on the property, particularly for larger projects like kitchen remodels or additions. Providing these documents to the appraiser shows that the work was done legally and to code, which can increase the property’s value.
- Warranty Information: If you’ve recently replaced major systems or appliances, such as HVAC systems, roofs, water heaters, provide the appraiser with warranty information. It’s an indication that the home is well-maintained and has reduced risk of future issues.
Enhance Curb Appeal
- Landscaping and Exterior Maintenance: The first impression is crucial. Ensure the lawn is mowed, shrubs are trimmed, and any outdoor plants are well-maintained. Simple additions like planting flowers or installing a few decorative garden features can make the property look more attractive and valuable.
- Exterior Repairs: Address any noticeable issues such as chipped paint, damaged siding, or broken fences. A well-maintained exterior indicates that the home has been taken care of and can positively influence the appraiser’s assessment.
- Exterior Touch-Ups: Adding a fresh coat of paint to the front door, replacing worn-out doormats, and ensuring the driveway is clean and in good condition can create a welcoming, well-kept appearance that sets the tone for the entire appraisal visit.
Work Closely with Your Real Estate Agent
- Provide Comparable Sales (Comps): Work with your agent to gather recent comparable sales in your area. These “comps” should be as similar as possible to your property in terms of size, style, age, and condition. Sharing this information with the appraiser ensures they have relevant, up-to-date data when evaluating your home.
- Highlight Unique Features: If your home has special features that might not be immediately obvious, like energy-efficient appliances, a recently upgraded kitchen, or custom landscaping, ask your agent to point these out to the appraiser. Providing this context can help the appraiser recognize the full value of the home’s unique features.
- Communication During the Appraisal: While it’s important not to interfere with the appraiser’s work, your agent can accompany them during the visit to answer any questions and provide additional information that might be helpful in understanding the property’s value.
By thoroughly preparing your home, providing comprehensive documentation, enhancing curb appeal, and leveraging the expertise of your real estate agent, you can significantly reduce the risk of a low home appraisal. Each of these steps plays a crucial role in showcasing your home’s value, helping to ensure that the appraisal accurately reflects the quality and condition of your property.
Additional Questions and Answers
Can a Seller Influence the Appraisal?
While it’s common for sellers to want to highlight their home’s best features, they should avoid trying to influence the appraiser directly. Appraisers are trained to be objective and can reject any information they view as an attempt to sway their judgment.
Can I Challenge a Low Appraisal?
Yes, if you receive an appraisal that you believe is inaccurate, you have the option to appeal. Gather evidence such as more recent comps, documentation of upgrades, and any discrepancies in the appraisal report. Work with your lender to submit a request for reconsideration.
Learn more:
The Ultimate Home Appraisal Checklist for Accurate Property Valuations
In summary, understanding what hurts a home appraisal and how to prepare for one can significantly influence your real estate experience. By maintaining your property, addressing maintenance issues, and providing thorough documentation, you can improve your chances of receiving a favorable appraisal. Whether buying, selling, or refinancing, being informed about the appraisal process helps you to make better decisions, impress the appraiser and make the most of your property’s value.
Don’t forget that if you receive a low appraisal, you have options to appeal and provide additional information to support your case. By taking a proactive approach, you can ensure the appraisal reflects your home’s true value.
